Kwashiorkor vs marasmus: protein vs energy deficiency
How to tell kwashiorkor from marasmus by what is missing, and why the round, swollen child is not the healthier one. Includes the textbook explanations of the oedema and the fatty liver.
Distinguish kwashiorkor from marasmus by protein versus total energy deficit, and explain the oedema and fatty liver of kwashiorkor.
The short version
- Marasmus is a shortage of total energy, calories and protein together: severe wasting, skin folds, no oedema, and often hunger.
- Kwashiorkor is classically a diet short of protein more than of energy; its defining sign is bilateral pitting oedema, with a fatty liver and lower albumin.
- Textbook explanation of the oedema: too little protein, too little albumin, lower plasma oncotic pressure, so fluid leaves the capillaries. Recent research says the full mechanism is not understood.
- Textbook explanation of the fatty liver: too little apolipoprotein B-100, so triglyceride cannot be exported as VLDL. This step has not been supported by recent measurements.
- Bilateral pitting oedema alone makes it severe acute malnutrition, so do not trust the scale: the fluid adds weight.
Two children, one village: who is healthier?
Two children arrive at a clinic from the same village. One is stick-thin, with loose skin hanging in folds. The other has a round face, swollen feet and a big belly, and looks better fed.
The round child is not the healthier one. This lesson shows how to tell kwashiorkor vs marasmus by what is missing, protein or total energy, and how to explain the oedema and the fatty liver.
Severe acute malnutrition: the three criteria
Both are forms of severe acute malnutrition (SAM) in young children. In children aged 6 to 59 months, it is defined by any one of three findings.[1][2][3]
- Weight-for-height z score below −3
- Mid-upper arm circumference (MUAC) under 11.5 cm
- Bilateral pitting nutritional oedema
Bilateral pitting oedema alone is enough.
Marasmus: a total energy deficit
Marasmus is a shortage of total energy: calories and protein together.[4][5]
The body breaks down its own fat and muscle for fuel, so the child is severely wasted, with stunted growth and skin hanging in folds. There is no oedema, and the child is often hungry.[1][5]
Kwashiorkor: protein deficit, oedema and fatty liver
Kwashiorkor is classically a diet short of protein more than of energy, as when a toddler is weaned onto a mostly starchy diet.[4][5]
Its defining sign is oedema, swelling of both feet and legs, and sometimes the face. Muscle may be partly kept, so the child can look less thin than in marasmus.[1][5]
The belly swells, partly from an enlarged, fatty liver. The hair turns thin and light, and the skin darkens, cracks and peels. The child is often irritable and apathetic, with little appetite.[1][5][9]
Albumin is lower in kwashiorkor than in marasmus.[1]
| Feature | Marasmus | Kwashiorkor |
|---|---|---|
| What is missing | Total energy: calories and protein together | Protein, more than energy |
| Oedema | None | Defining sign: both feet and legs, sometimes the face |
| Body | Severely wasted, skin in folds, stunted growth | Muscle may be partly kept; may look less thin |
| Liver and belly | Not described | Enlarged, fatty liver; swollen belly |
| Hair and skin | Not described | Thin, light hair; dark, cracked, peeling skin |
| Behaviour | Often hungry | Irritable, apathetic, little appetite |
| Albumin | Higher than in kwashiorkor | Lower |
Why the oedema: low albumin and oncotic pressure
The textbook explanation runs in four steps: too little protein, so the liver makes too little albumin; low albumin lowers the oncotic pressure in the plasma; so fluid leaves the capillaries and collects in the tissues.[1][5][9]
Why the fatty liver: apoB-100 and VLDL
The textbook explanation: too little protein means too little apolipoprotein B-100. Without it, the liver cannot package triglyceride into VLDL and export it, so fat piles up in the liver cells.[1]
The fatty change usually improves once protein and micronutrients are given.[1][7]
Two children: why the scale can mislead
Take two children. Child A has a weight-for-height z score of −3.4 and no oedema. Child B has −2.1, an arm circumference of 12.4 cm, and pitting oedema of both feet.
- Child A: z = −3.4, below −3, so A qualifies on weight; no oedema, so marasmus
- Child B: z = −2.1, not below −3, so B misses the weight cutoff
- Child B: MUAC 12.4 cm, not under 11.5 cm, so B misses the arm cutoff
- Child B: pitting oedema of both feet, so B qualifies through the oedema: kwashiorkor
That is why the scale alone can mislead: the fluid adds weight.
Feeding must be restarted with care, because treatment itself can cause refeeding syndrome, with fluid overload and electrolyte deficits.[5][8]
Practice question
Original · USMLE styleA 2-year-old girl is brought to the clinic by her mother because of swelling of her feet and face for 2 weeks. Four months ago, when her baby brother was born, she was weaned and has since been fed mostly maize porridge, with little milk, eggs, legumes or meat. She is irritable and apathetic. Examination shows pitting oedema of both feet and shins, a distended abdomen with the liver edge palpable 4 cm below the right costal margin, thin light-coloured hair, and dark cracked patches of skin on the legs. Laboratory studies show:
| Serum albumin | 1.8 g/dL |
|---|---|
| Urinalysis, protein | negative |
Common questions
What is the difference between kwashiorkor and marasmus?
Marasmus is a shortage of total energy, calories and protein together, with severe wasting and no oedema. Kwashiorkor is classically a diet short of protein more than of energy, and its defining sign is oedema.
How is severe acute malnutrition defined in children?
By a weight-for-height z score below −3, or a mid-upper arm circumference under 11.5 cm, or bilateral pitting nutritional oedema. Any one is enough, and oedema alone qualifies.
Why does kwashiorkor cause oedema?
The textbook explanation is that too little protein means too little albumin, which lowers the plasma oncotic pressure so fluid leaves the capillaries. Recent research says oedema does not track albumin neatly and the full mechanism is not understood.
Why does kwashiorkor cause a fatty liver?
The standard teaching is that too little apolipoprotein B-100 stops the liver packaging triglyceride into VLDL for export, so fat builds up. Recent measurements have not supported that step, and the cause is uncertain.
Why can the scale mislead in kwashiorkor?
Oedema fluid adds weight, so a child can miss the weight-for-height cutoff yet still qualify as severe acute malnutrition through bilateral pitting oedema.
Transcript
Read the full narration, by chapter698 words
0:00Two children, one village: who is healthier?
Two children arrive at a clinic from the same village. One is stick-thin, with loose skin hanging in folds. The other has a round face, swollen feet and a big belly, and looks better fed. But the round child is not the healthier one. Why? Today: tell kwashiorkor from marasmus by what is missing, protein or total energy, and explain the oedema and the fatty liver.
0:26Severe acute malnutrition: the three criteria
Both are forms of severe acute malnutrition in young children. It is defined by a weight-for-height z score below minus three, or a mid-upper arm circumference under 11.5 centimetres, or bilateral pitting nutritional oedema. Bilateral pitting oedema alone is enough. Marasmus is a shortage of total energy:
0:47Marasmus: a total energy deficit
calories and protein together. The body breaks down its own fat and muscle for fuel, so the child is severely wasted, with stunted growth and skin hanging in folds. There is no oedema, and the child is often hungry.
1:05Kwashiorkor: protein deficit, oedema, fatty liver, albumin
Kwashiorkor is classically a diet short of protein more than of energy, as when a toddler is weaned onto a mostly starchy diet. Its defining sign is oedema, swelling of both feet and legs, and sometimes the face. Muscle may be partly kept, so the child can look less thin than in marasmus. The belly swells, partly from an enlarged, fatty liver. The hair turns thin and light, and the skin darkens, cracks and peels. The child is often irritable and apathetic, with little appetite. Albumin is lower in kwashiorkor than in marasmus.
1:44The oedema: low albumin and oncotic pressure
Now the textbook explanation for the oedema. Too little protein, so the liver makes too little albumin. Low albumin lowers the oncotic pressure in the plasma, so fluid leaves the capillaries and collects in the tissues. Recent research adds a caution: oedema does not track albumin levels neatly, and the full mechanism is still not understood.
2:08The fatty liver: apoB-100 and VLDL
The textbook explanation for the fatty liver: too little protein means too little apolipoprotein B 100. Without it, the liver cannot package triglyceride into VLDL and export it, so fat piles up in the liver cells. Recent measurements have not supported that step, and the cause is uncertain, but it is the standard teaching. The fatty change usually improves once protein and micronutrients are given.
2:37Two children: why the scale can mislead
Take two children. A has a weight-for-height z score of minus 3.4 and no oedema. B has minus 2.1, an arm circumference of 12.4 centimetres, and swollen feet. A qualifies on weight, and has marasmus. B misses the weight cutoff, but qualifies through the oedema, so B is kwashiorkor. That is why the scale alone can mislead you: the fluid adds weight. Feeding must be restarted with care, because treatment itself can cause refeeding syndrome, with fluid overload and electrolyte deficits.
3:15Practice question
Your turn. A 2-year-old girl is brought in because of swelling of her feet and face for two weeks. Four months ago, when her baby brother was born, she was weaned onto mostly maize porridge, with little milk, eggs, legumes or meat. She is irritable and apathetic, with pitting oedema of both feet and shins, a distended abdomen, a liver edge four centimetres below the costal margin, thin light hair, and dark cracked skin. Serum albumin is 1.8 grams per decilitre, and urine protein is negative. Which dietary pattern most likely preceded this condition? A, low energy and low protein. B, low energy and adequate protein. C, adequate energy and low protein. D, excess energy and adequate protein. E, adequate energy and protein, with low micronutrients. Pause here and decide.
4:19The answer, one option at a time
A is out: that is the marasmus pattern, with wasting and no oedema. B is out: that pattern lacks the protein shortage behind the low albumin and oedema. D is out: that is overnutrition, not the low-albumin undernutrition picture here. E is out: micronutrient lack can worsen kwashiorkor, but it does not define it. So the answer is C. Adequate energy with too little protein gives low albumin, oedema and a fatty liver: kwashiorkor.
4:53Recap and the next lesson
Three things to keep. One: marasmus is a total energy deficit, with wasting and no oedema. Two: kwashiorkor is a protein deficit, with oedema, a fatty liver and lower albumin. Three: oedema alone makes it severe acute malnutrition, so do not trust the scale. Next, refeeding syndrome.
Sources
Numbers in the text, e.g. [1], point here- Adaptive Responses in Severe Acute Malnutrition. Europe PMC PMC12430813. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC12430813
- Severe acute malnutrition criteria review. Europe PMC PMC13623131. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC13623131
- Severe acute malnutrition definition (WHO criteria). Europe PMC PMC13475133. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC13475133
- Malnutrition review (marasmus and kwashiorkor). Europe PMC PMC13346808. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC13346808
- MSD Manual Professional Version. Protein-Energy Undernutrition. msdmanuals.com/professional/nutritional-disorders/undernutrition/protein-energy-undernutrition
- Kwashiorkor: cause and pathogenesis (caveat sources). Europe PMC PMC13669358 · PMC5986532. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC13669358 · europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC5986532
- Hepatic steatosis in malnutrition, case report. Europe PMC PMC11934548. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC11934548
- Refeeding syndrome in severe acute malnutrition. Europe PMC PMC12468821. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC12468821
- Kwashiorkor. Wikipedia (secondary). en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kwashiorkor
The two worked-example children and all values on them are teaching examples. The drawings are schematic teaching models, not to scale; the figures carry no measurements.
The practice question is original and its patient is synthetic. Every fact is checked against the sources above in independent accuracy reviews. Always follow your local guidelines and your own laboratory’s ranges.
Image credits. Illustrations: Servier Medical Art (smart.servier.com), CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), adapted (cropped, recoloured, outlined, overlaid with hand-drawn signs): child figures, adipose tissue, muscle, liver. Hepatocyte: NIAID NIH BioArt Source (bioart.niaid.nih.gov/bioart/203), public domain. The energy and protein bars, capillary and VLDL diagrams, worked-example cards, scale sketch, question card, pocket card and all handwriting are drawn in code (original). No AI-generated teaching images.
Corrections. None so far. Spotted an error? Email info@medservatory.com with the lesson code MS-S1-NUTR-005.
For exam study only, not medical advice. Read the medical disclaimer.
In this series
Playlist on YouTube- EP 01Thiamine deficiency: Wernicke–Korsakoff and beriberi5:09
- EP 02Niacin (vitamin B3), tryptophan and pellagra explained5:15
- EP 03Fat-soluble vitamins A, D, E and K: functions, deficiency, toxicity5:21
- EP 04Vitamin C and collagen synthesis: why scurvy bleeds5:08
- EP 05Kwashiorkor vs marasmus: protein vs energy deficiency5:20
- EP 06Fat-soluble vs water-soluble vitamins: storage and toxicity5:32