Acute shortness of breath: the differential and first tests
Sort the causes of acute shortness of breath by where the oxygen road breaks, check for red flags first, then choose the first tests that separate the heart from the lungs.
Chapters (12)
Build a prioritized differential for acute dyspnea and choose the first tests that discriminate cardiac, pulmonary and other causes.
The short version
- Sort acute shortness of breath by where the oxygen road breaks: airway, lung and pleura, blood vessels, heart.
- Check red flags and oxygen saturation first; a saturation below 90% signals something serious, but a normal one does not exclude a serious cause.
- Run three first moves in parallel: an ECG in most adults, a chest x-ray in most patients, and a focused bedside history and exam.
- BNP separates cardiac from pulmonary causes: a low level helps rule out heart failure, a high level supports it but is not specific.
- D-dimer only helps when the chance of pulmonary embolism is low or unlikely; otherwise go to CT angiography, or less often a V/Q scan.
A breathless patient: where to start with acute shortness of breath
A 53-year-old woman is sitting bolt upright on the stretcher, gasping, barely able to finish a sentence. Her oxygen saturation is 87%. Breathlessness has many causes, and some can kill her in minutes.
This lesson gives a working approach to acute shortness of breath: a prioritised list of causes, a fast check for danger, and the first tests that separate the heart from the lungs.[1][3]
The oxygen road: sort the causes by where it breaks
Oxygen has to travel a road to the tissues. Sorting causes by where the road breaks gives a list that is easy to hold in your head. The grouping is a teaching device; the causes themselves come from standard references.[1][3]
| Where the road breaks | Causes |
|---|---|
| Airway | Asthma, anaphylaxis, a foreign body |
| Lung and pleura | Pneumonia, COPD exacerbation, pneumothorax |
| Blood vessels | Pulmonary embolism |
| Heart | Acute coronary syndrome, heart failure with pulmonary edema, cardiac tamponade |
Red flags and oxygen saturation come first
Before sorting anything, check whether the patient is in trouble right now. The red flags are:[1][3]
- low blood pressure
- low oxygen
- altered mental status
- stridor
- blue lips
- heavy use of the neck muscles
- absent breath sounds
Three first moves in parallel: ECG, chest x-ray, bedside exam
The first tests run side by side rather than one after another.[1]
- ECG in most adultsIt looks for myocardial ischemia. Acute coronary syndrome can show up as breathlessness alone.[1][3][6]
- Chest x-ray in most patientsIt can show a pneumothorax, pulmonary edema or a pneumonia. In heart failure, look for an enlarged heart, pleural fluid and Kerley B lines.[2][3]
- Bedside history and examThese decide everything else.[1]
Bedside clues: pneumothorax, pulmonary embolism, asthma and tamponade
| Finding | Points to |
|---|---|
| Sudden sharp chest pain, quiet breath sounds and a hyperresonant percussion note on one side | Pneumothorax[1][5] |
| Sudden sharp chest pain with a fast heart rate and no other explanation | Pulmonary embolism[1] |
| Wheeze | The airway: think asthma[1][7] |
| Low blood pressure with pulsus paradoxus | Tamponade[1][8] |
Pulsus paradoxus means a systolic drop of more than 10 mm Hg on inspiration.[8] Echocardiography is the test that confirms tamponade: it shows the fluid around the heart and the pressure on the chambers.[1][8]
Heart or lung? BNP and its limits
The cardiac versus lung puzzle is the one the exam loves. A blood test called BNP helps here. A low level helps rule out heart failure.[2][3] A commonly used threshold is 100 pg/mL.[2]
The last piece: pulmonary embolism, D-dimer or CT angiography
If the chance of pulmonary embolism is low or unlikely, a normal D-dimer effectively excludes it.[1][3]
If the chance is likely or high and nothing else explains the picture, go to CT angiography; a V/Q scan is used less often, for example when contrast is a problem.[1][3]
Practice question
Original · USMLE styleA 66-year-old man comes to the emergency department because of worsening shortness of breath for 2 days. He has a history of COPD and hypertension. He has noted swelling of both ankles. Temperature is 37.0°C (98.6°F), pulse is 104/min, respirations are 24/min, and blood pressure is 142/84 mm Hg. Oxygen saturation is 91% on room air. He is able to speak in short sentences. Diffuse expiratory wheezes are heard bilaterally, and there is 1+ pitting edema of both ankles. An ECG shows sinus tachycardia and no ischemic changes. A chest x-ray shows hyperinflation, a borderline heart size, and no consolidation, pleural effusion, or pneumothorax.
Common questions
What are the first tests for acute shortness of breath?
Pulse oximetry on every patient, an ECG in most adults and a chest x-ray in most patients, together with a focused bedside history and exam.
Does a normal oxygen saturation rule out a serious cause of dyspnea?
No. A saturation below 90% signals something serious, but a normal saturation does not exclude a serious cause.
Can BNP tell heart failure from a lung cause of dyspnea?
A low BNP helps rule out heart failure and a high one supports it. It is not specific, and up to 30% of patients with acute heart failure with preserved ejection fraction fall below the common 100 pg/mL threshold.
When does a D-dimer help in suspected pulmonary embolism?
When the chance of embolism is low or unlikely on a clinical score, where a normal result effectively excludes it. With a likely or high chance, go straight to CT angiography. Scoring detail is covered in the pulmonary embolism lesson.
What does pulsus paradoxus suggest?
Together with low blood pressure it should make you think of tamponade. It is a systolic drop of more than 10 mm Hg on inspiration, and echocardiography confirms the diagnosis.
Transcript
Read the full narration, by chapter679 words
0:00The case: a breathless woman, SpO2 87 %
A 53-year-old woman is sitting bolt upright on the stretcher, gasping, and she can barely finish a sentence. Her oxygen saturation is 87%. Breathlessness has many causes, and some can kill her in minutes. By the end of this lesson, you'll build a prioritized list of causes for acute shortness of breath, and pick the first tests that separate the heart from the lungs.
0:25The oxygen road: sort causes by where it breaks
Start with one idea: the oxygen has to travel a road, so sort the causes by where the road breaks. The airway: asthma, anaphylaxis, a foreign body. The lung and the pleura: pneumonia, COPD exacerbation, pneumothorax. The blood vessels: pulmonary embolism. The heart: acute coronary syndrome, heart failure with pulmonary edema, cardiac tamponade.
0:52Red flags and oxygen saturation first
Before any of that, check whether she's in trouble right now. Red flags are low blood pressure, low oxygen, altered mental status, stridor, blue lips, heavy use of the neck muscles, and absent breath sounds. Pulse oximetry goes on every patient. A saturation below 90% signals something serious, but a normal saturation does not exclude a serious cause.
1:18Three first moves in parallel: the ECG
Now the tests. Think of three first moves that run in parallel. One: an ECG in most adults, to look for myocardial ischemia. Acute coronary syndrome can show up as breathlessness alone. Two: a chest x-ray in most patients.
1:34Chest x-ray: pneumothorax, edema, pneumonia, Kerley B lines
It can show a pneumothorax, pulmonary edema, or a pneumonia. In heart failure, look for an enlarged heart, pleural fluid, and Kerley B lines.
1:47Bedside history and exam: pneumothorax, PE, asthma
Three: bedside history and exam, which decide everything else. Sudden sharp chest pain with quiet breath sounds and a hyperresonant percussion note on one side points to pneumothorax. Sudden sharp chest pain with a fast heart rate and no other explanation points to pulmonary embolism. Wheeze points to the airway, so think asthma.
2:10Tamponade: pulsus paradoxus and echocardiography
Low blood pressure with a pulsus paradoxus, meaning a systolic drop of more than 10 millimeters of mercury on inspiration, should make you think of tamponade. And echocardiography is the test that confirms it: it shows the fluid around the heart and the pressure on the chambers.
2:28Heart or lung? BNP and its limits
Then comes the cardiac versus lung puzzle, which is the one the exam loves. A blood test called BNP helps here. A low level helps rule out heart failure. A commonly used threshold is 100 picograms per milliliter. But up to 30% of patients with acute heart failure with preserved ejection fraction fall below it, and obesity lowers the level too. A high level supports heart failure, but it isn't specific: age, kidney failure, acute coronary syndrome, and a large pulmonary embolism can all raise it.
3:04The last piece: pulmonary embolism, D-dimer or CT angiography
The last piece is pulmonary embolism. If the chance is low or unlikely, a normal D-dimer effectively excludes it. If the chance is likely or high and nothing else explains the picture, you go to CT angiography, or a VQ scan if contrast is a problem.
3:23Your turn: practice question
Your turn. Pause if you want to work it out. A 66-year-old man with COPD and hypertension has had 2 days of worsening breathlessness. He has ankle swelling and wheezing. His temperature is 37 degrees Celsius, his pulse is 104, and his oxygen saturation is 91% on room air. The ECG shows sinus tachycardia only. The chest x-ray shows hyperinflation, a borderline heart size, and no consolidation or pneumothorax. Which test would best separate a cardiac from a pulmonary cause of his breathlessness?
4:05The answer and why each option is right or wrong
The answer is D: a BNP level. A low result argues strongly against heart failure, which points back to his lungs. A, bronchoscopy, looks inside the airways, but nothing here suggests an airway lesion. B, CT angiography, and C, D-dimer, answer the embolism question, and the story doesn't point to a clot. E, spirometry, measures airflow limitation, but it can't exclude heart failure.
4:35High-yield recap and next lesson
Quick recap. One: sort breathlessness by where the oxygen road breaks, and check for red flags and oxygen saturation first. Two: start with pulse oximetry, an ECG, and a chest x-ray. Three: BNP separates cardiac from pulmonary causes, and D-dimer only helps when the chance of embolism is low. Next: a sudden swelling of the airway and a falling blood pressure. That's anaphylaxis.
Sources
Numbers in the text, e.g. [1], point here- MSD Manual Professional Version. Dyspnea. msdmanuals.com/professional/pulmonary-disorders/symptoms-of-pulmonary-disorders/dyspnea
- MSD Manual Professional Version. Heart Failure. msdmanuals.com/professional/cardiovascular-disorders/heart-failure/heart-failure-hf
- Wikipedia. Shortness of breath (secondary source). en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shortness_of_breath
- Initial assessment of respiratory distress, Ann Intensive Care 2026. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC12934415
- Pneumothorax emergency protocol, Interv Pain Med 2026. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC13254988
- Acute coronary syndrome in elderly patients, J Clin Med 2024. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC11478011
- Acute severe asthma in adolescents and adults, J Clin Med 2019. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC6780340
- Pericardial effusion and tamponade (pulsus paradoxus over 10 mm Hg). and europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC12985857 · europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC9399526
- Obesity and natriuretic peptide levels. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC13488223
The practice question is original and its patient is synthetic. Every fact is checked against the sources above in independent accuracy reviews. Always follow your local guidelines and your own laboratory’s ranges.
Image credits. Illustrations: Servier Medical Art (smart.servier.com), CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), adapted (recoloured, outlined, resized). Pulse oximeter icon: Health Icons (CC0). Blood sample tube: Marcel Tisch via Bioicons (CC0). Echocardiography image: DBCLS via Bioicons (CC BY 4.0). The seated patient, oxygen road, ECG strip, chest x-ray overlays, number lines, cards and all handwriting are drawn in code (original). No AI-generated teaching images.
Corrections. None so far. Spotted an error? Email info@medservatory.com with the lesson code MS-CK-EMER-009.
For exam study only, not medical advice. Read the medical disclaimer.
In this series
Playlist on YouTube- EP 01Types of shock: telling the four patterns apart at the bedside5:07
- EP 02Sepsis and septic shock: the first hour in order5:11
- EP 03Tension pneumothorax vs cardiac tamponade: obstructive shock5:11
- EP 04Trauma primary survey: the xABCDE order5:11
- EP 05Acute shortness of breath: the differential and first tests5:08
- EP 06Anaphylaxis treatment: recognition and epinephrine first5:29
- EP 07Unstable tachycardia: synchronized cardioversion or drugs?5:08
- EP 08Bradycardia management: atropine, pacing and AV block types5:04
- EP 09Altered mental status workup: the initial six steps5:26
- EP 10Acetaminophen overdose: the nomogram, NAPQI and NAC4:57