Types of shock: telling the four patterns apart at the bedside
Two patients can share the same blood pressure and need opposite treatment. Use the tank, pump and pipes model, then skin, neck veins and lungs, to name the type of shock.
Chapters (13)
Differentiate hypovolemic, cardiogenic, distributive and obstructive shock by bedside findings and hemodynamic profile (CO, SVR, filling pressures).
The short version
- Shock is acute circulatory failure with inadequate cellular oxygen use; lactate is typically above 2 mmol/L and low blood pressure is not required.
- There are four patterns: three low-flow types (hypovolemic, cardiogenic, obstructive) and one high-flow type (distributive).
- Blood pressure is roughly cardiac output × systemic vascular resistance, and cardiac output is heart rate × stroke volume.
- Ask two questions: is the skin cold or warm, and are the neck veins full or flat? Then check the lungs.
- The type decides the treatment, so name it before you treat.
Two patients, same pressure, opposite problems
Two patients lie in neighboring bays, and both have a blood pressure of 80/50 mm Hg. One has warm, flushed hands and a bounding pulse. The other has cold, clammy skin and a weak, rapid pulse.
Same pressure, opposite problems, and the right treatment for one can harm the other. This page covers the types of shock and how to tell them apart at the bedside.[1][2]
What shock is: failed oxygen delivery
Shock is acute circulatory failure: cells cannot use enough oxygen, so blood lactate rises, typically above 2 mmol/L (18 mg/dL).[1][2]
Low blood pressure is common, but it is not required for the diagnosis.[1][2]
The model: BP = CO × SVR, and the tank, pump and pipes
CO = cardiac output; SVR = systemic vascular resistance; CO = HR × SV (heart rate × stroke volume)
Blood pressure is roughly cardiac output × systemic vascular resistance, and cardiac output is heart rate × stroke volume.[4][2] Stroke volume depends on how well the heart fills and empties.[2] So picture a tank (the blood volume), a pump (the heart) and the pipes (the vessels).
Shock has four patterns: three with low flow, which are hypovolemic, cardiogenic and obstructive, and one with high flow, which is distributive.[1][2] The tank, pump and pipes picture is a teaching device.
The three low-flow types of shock
Hypovolemic shock: the tank is empty. The cause is bleeding, vomiting, diarrhea or burns. Less blood returns, so filling pressures and stroke volume fall, and the body squeezes the pipes, so resistance rises. At the bedside: cold, clammy skin, slow capillary refill, a fast pulse, and flat or collapsed neck veins.[1][2][3]
Cardiogenic shock: the pump fails. The heart itself fails, most often from a large myocardial infarction. Output falls, blood backs up behind the failing ventricle, and resistance rises. The skin is cold, the neck veins are usually full, and the lungs are wet, with crackles.[2][3]
Obstructive shock: a blockage. Something outside the heart muscle stops filling or emptying: tension pneumothorax, cardiac tamponade or a massive pulmonary embolism. Output falls, resistance rises, the skin is cold and the neck veins are distended. But there is no pulmonary edema, so unlike the failing pump there are no crackles. In tension pneumothorax, breath sounds are absent on one side.[1][2][3]
Distributive shock: the pipes, and the hemodynamic profile of each type
In distributive shock, vasodilation drops resistance. The blood volume is normal, but the vessels are too wide for it. Sepsis is the classic cause, then anaphylaxis, and neurogenic shock after a spinal cord injury, usually above the fourth thoracic level (T4).[1][2][3]
Cardiac output is usually high, so the skin is warm and flushed, with a bounding pulse.[1][2]
| Type | CO | SVR | Filling pressure | Skin and neck veins |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hypovolemic | Down | Up | Down | Cold, clammy; flat or collapsed veins |
| Cardiogenic | Down | Up | Wedge pressure up | Cold; full veins; crackles |
| Obstructive | Down | Up | Normal or up (central venous pressure up) | Cold; distended veins; no crackles |
| Distributive | Usually up | Down | Normal or down | Warm, flushed; bounding pulse |
CO is cardiac output and SVR is systemic vascular resistance. Filling pressure means wedge pressure (left side) and central venous pressure (right side).[3][1]
The bedside rule: skin, neck veins, then lungs
Clinical evaluation of skin perfusion and jugular vein distension usually points toward the type of shock.[1] The rule needs two questions: is the skin cold or warm, and are the neck veins full or flat?
- Warm skinPoints to distributive shock.
- Cold skin, flat neck veinsHypovolemic shock.
- Cold skin, full neck veins, wet lungsCardiogenic shock.
- Cold skin, full neck veins, no pulmonary edemaObstructive shock.
If the picture is unclear, a bedside echocardiogram sorts the type in minutes.[1][2]
The type decides the treatment
Fluids suit an empty tank, but take caution when the lungs are wet.[2] This is why naming the type comes before treating: a fluid bolus that helps one patient can harm the other.
Treatment of sepsis and of the chest emergencies behind obstructive shock is covered in later lessons.
Practice question
Original · USMLE styleA 69-year-old man is brought to the emergency department 3 hours after the onset of crushing substernal chest pressure. He has hypertension and type 2 diabetes mellitus. Temperature is 36.7°C (98.1°F), pulse is 116/min, respirations are 28/min, and blood pressure is 88/58 mm Hg. Oxygen saturation is 89% on room air. He is anxious and diaphoretic. The skin is cool and clammy, and capillary refill time is 5 seconds. The jugular veins are distended to the angle of the jaw. Crackles are heard at both lung bases, and a third heart sound is present. An ECG shows ST-segment elevation in leads V1 through V4. A pulmonary artery catheter is placed.
Common questions
What are the four types of shock?
Hypovolemic, cardiogenic, obstructive and distributive. The first three are low-flow states and distributive shock is the high-flow state.
How do you tell the types of shock apart at the bedside?
Ask whether the skin is cold or warm and whether the neck veins are full or flat, then check the lungs. Warm skin points to distributive shock.
Is low blood pressure required to diagnose shock?
No. Shock is acute circulatory failure with inadequate cellular oxygen use, and low blood pressure is common but not required.
What lactate level suggests shock?
Lactate is typically above 2 mmol/L (18 mg/dL) in shock states.
Can shock be more than one type?
Yes. Types can combine, and late septic shock can turn cold.
Transcript
Read the full narration, by chapter709 words
0:00The case: two patients, same blood pressure, opposite problems
Two patients lie in neighboring bays, and both have a blood pressure of 80 over 50. One has warm, flushed hands and a bounding pulse. The other has cold, clammy skin and a weak, rapid pulse. Same pressure, opposite problems, and the right treatment for one can harm the other. By the end of this lesson, you'll tell the four types of shock apart at the bedside. Shock is acute circulatory failure:
0:25What shock is: failed oxygen delivery, lactate above 2 mmol/L
cells can't use enough oxygen, so the blood lactate rises, typically above two millimoles per liter. Low blood pressure is common, but it isn't required for the diagnosis.
0:39The model: BP = CO x SVR, CO = HR x SV
Now the model from your physiology. Blood pressure is roughly cardiac output times systemic vascular resistance. Cardiac output is heart rate times stroke volume, and stroke volume depends on how well the heart fills and empties.
0:54Tank, pump and pipes: four patterns, three low flow, one high flow
So picture a tank, a pump, and the pipes. Shock has four patterns: three with low flow, which are hypovolemic, cardiogenic, and obstructive, and one with high flow, which is distributive.
1:08Hypovolemic shock: the tank is empty
Start with the tank. In hypovolemic shock, the tank is empty from bleeding, vomiting, diarrhea, or burns. Less blood returns, so filling pressures and stroke volume fall, and the body squeezes the pipes, so resistance rises. At the bedside: cold, clammy skin, slow capillary refill, a fast pulse, and flat or collapsed neck veins. Next, the pump.
1:34Cardiogenic shock: the pump fails, wedge pressure rises
In cardiogenic shock the heart itself fails, most often from a large myocardial infarction. Output falls, blood backs up behind the failing ventricle, and resistance rises. The skin is cold again, but now the neck veins are full, and the lungs are wet, with crackles.
1:54Obstructive shock: a blockage stops the pump
Third, a blockage. In obstructive shock, something outside the heart muscle stops filling or emptying: tension pneumothorax, cardiac tamponade, or a massive pulmonary embolism. Output falls, resistance rises, the skin is cold, and the neck veins are distended. But there's no pulmonary edema, so unlike the failing pump there are no crackles. In tension pneumothorax, breath sounds are absent on one side.
2:24Distributive shock: the pipes themselves, vasodilation
Last, the pipes themselves. In distributive shock, vasodilation drops resistance, and the blood volume is normal but the vessels are too wide for it. Sepsis is the classic cause, then anaphylaxis, and neurogenic shock after a spinal cord injury above the fourth thoracic level. Cardiac output is usually high, so the skin is warm and flushed, with a bounding pulse. The catch is that late septic shock can turn cold, and types can combine, so keep looking.
2:56The bedside rule: skin, neck veins, lungs
So the bedside rule needs two questions. Is the skin cold or warm, and are the neck veins full or flat? Warm skin points to distributive. Cold with flat veins is hypovolemic; cold with full veins and wet lungs is cardiogenic; cold with full veins and no pulmonary edema is obstructive. If it's unclear, a bedside echocardiogram sorts the type in minutes. And the type decides the treatment: fluids for an empty tank, but caution when the lungs are wet.
3:29Your turn: a practice question
Your turn. Pause if you want to work it out. A 69-year-old man arrives 3 hours after the onset of crushing chest pressure. His blood pressure is 88 over 58, and his pulse is 116. His skin is cold and clammy, his neck veins are distended, he has crackles at both lung bases, and a third heart sound. The ECG shows ST elevation in the anterior leads. Which set of hemodynamic findings is most likely?
4:01The options, wrong ones first
A is high output with low resistance, which is distributive, and his skin would be warm. B is an empty tank, but his neck veins are full, not flat. D, with a normal wedge pressure, fits a pulmonary embolism, but that patient has no pulmonary congestion. E has low resistance, which doesn't fit cold skin.
4:23The answer: low output, high resistance, high wedge pressure
The answer is C: low output, high resistance, and a high wedge pressure. The failing left ventricle backs blood into the lungs, and the body squeezes the pipes to compensate.
4:36High-yield recap and next lesson
Quick recap. One: shock is a failure of oxygen delivery, with three low-flow types and one high-flow type. Two: is the skin cold or warm, are the neck veins full or flat, then check the lungs. Three: the type decides the fix, so name it before you treat. Next: sepsis, shock caused by infection, and how to recognize and prioritize it.
Sources
Numbers in the text, e.g. [1], point here- Cecconi M, et al. Consensus on circulatory shock and hemodynamic monitoring. Task force of the European Society of Intensive Care Medicine. Intensive Care Med 2014;40:1795-1815. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC4239778
- MSD Manual Professional Version. Shock and Fluid Resuscitation: Shock. msdmanuals.com/professional/critical-care-medicine/shock-and-fluid-resuscitation/shock
- Life in the Fast Lane (LITFL). Shock. litfl.com/shock/
- Mean arterial pressure (background for BP = CO x SVR). en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mean_arterial_pressure
The practice question is original and its patient is synthetic. Every fact is checked against the sources above in independent accuracy reviews. Always follow your local guidelines and your own laboratory’s ranges.
Image credits. Illustrations: Servier Medical Art (smart.servier.com), CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), adapted (recoloured, outlined, labelled): heart, vasoconstriction, vasodilatation, blood bag, burns, wet lungs, pneumothorax, normal lungs, cardiac tamponade, pulmonary embolism, vertebra, bacterium. Hand icon and head-neck veins icon by Servier via bioicons.com, CC BY 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/), adapted (recoloured, labelled). Echocardiography icon by DBCLS via bioicons.com, CC BY 4.0, adapted. Original diagrams: the blood-pressure cards, lactate slip, tank, pump and pipes model, profile notes, decision tree, schematic ECG strip, question card and pocket card. No AI-generated teaching images.
Corrections. None so far. Spotted an error? Email info@medservatory.com with the lesson code MS-CK-EMER-007.
For exam study only, not medical advice. Read the medical disclaimer.
In this series
Playlist on YouTube- EP 01Types of shock: telling the four patterns apart at the bedside5:07
- EP 02Sepsis and septic shock: the first hour in order5:11
- EP 03Tension pneumothorax vs cardiac tamponade: obstructive shock5:11
- EP 04Trauma primary survey: the xABCDE order5:11
- EP 05Acute shortness of breath: the differential and first tests5:08
- EP 06Anaphylaxis treatment: recognition and epinephrine first5:29
- EP 07Unstable tachycardia: synchronized cardioversion or drugs?5:08
- EP 08Bradycardia management: atropine, pacing and AV block types5:04
- EP 09Altered mental status workup: the initial six steps5:26
- EP 10Acetaminophen overdose: the nomogram, NAPQI and NAC4:57