USMLE Step 2 CKEmergency medicine and acute careEP 03 of 10

Tension pneumothorax vs cardiac tamponade: obstructive shock

Both cause low blood pressure and distended neck veins, and both need the obstruction removed. Learn the bedside findings that tell tension pneumothorax from cardiac tamponade, and the immediate fix for each.

  • 5:11 video
  • 3 min read
  • 10 sources
  • Published 16 Nov 2026
Chapters (13)
By the end of this lesson

Distinguish tension pneumothorax from cardiac tamponade as causes of obstructive shock and choose the immediate intervention for each: needle decompression then chest tube, or pericardiocentesis (surgical drainage in trauma).

The short version

  1. Tension pneumothorax and cardiac tamponade are both obstructive shock: low cardiac output, raised venous pressure, and a fix that removes the obstruction.
  2. Tension pneumothorax is a clinical diagnosis: do not wait for a chest x-ray. Treat with needle decompression, then a chest tube.
  3. Tension pneumothorax: one-sided decreased or absent breath sounds, hyperresonance, and in a large one a trachea shifted away from that side.
  4. Cardiac tamponade: muffled heart sounds, pulsus paradoxus (systolic fall of more than 10 mm Hg on inspiration), and an effusion on ultrasound.
  5. Tamponade is treated by draining the pericardium, usually by pericardiocentesis; in trauma, pericardiocentesis is a temporizing step and surgery is more definitive.

Obstructive shock: what tension pneumothorax and tamponade share

A man has been stabbed in the chest and his blood pressure is 70/40 mm Hg. His neck veins are swollen and his heart is racing. A needle in the chest wall might save him; so might fluid drained from around the heart. Which one he needs depends on what you find, which is the whole point of tension pneumothorax vs cardiac tamponade.

Both are obstructive shock: the heart muscle is fine, but something blocks blood from getting into it or out of it. Cardiac output falls, and because blood is backing up behind the block, venous pressure rises.[2][3]

That is why both classically show low blood pressure and distended neck veins.[2] The fix follows from the mechanism: remove the obstruction.[2][3][6]

Tension pneumothorax: mechanism and bedside signs

Air enters the pleural space and cannot get out, so the pressure inside that side of the chest keeps climbing. The rising pressure squeezes the great veins, and venous return, the preload, falls.[3][5][6]

  • Hypotension.
  • Decreased or absent breath sounds on the affected side.
  • A hyperresonant percussion note on that side.
  • In a large pneumothorax, the trachea shifts away from the affected side.

In a patient on a ventilator, a sudden drop in blood pressure should make you think of tension pneumothorax.[1][6]

Needle decompression, then a chest tube

Treatment is decompression with a large-bore needle, then placement of a chest tube. Needle first, tube next.[1][6]

In adults, the needle site is the fourth or fifth intercostal space, just in front of the midaxillary line. The second intercostal space in the midclavicular line is the traditional alternative.[1][5][10]

A chest tube drains air or fluid from the pleural space. It does not drain the pericardium.

Cardiac tamponade: fluid in the pericardial sac

In cardiac tamponade, fluid collects in the pericardial sac with enough pressure to stop the heart filling.[2]

Speed matters more than volume. If fluid builds slowly, the pericardium stretches and can hold up to about 2 L. If it builds fast, as in trauma, about 150 mL can be enough.[2][7][8]

Rate of accumulation in cardiac tamponade
How the fluid buildsVolume that can be enough
Slowly (pericardium stretches)Up to about 2 L
Fast, as in traumaAbout 150 mL

The classic clues are Beck's triad: low blood pressure, muffled heart sounds, and raised venous pressure. But the triad is often incomplete, so do not wait for all three.[2][4][9]

Pulsus paradoxus and ultrasound in cardiac tamponade

A second clue is pulsus paradoxus: a fall in systolic pressure of more than 10 mm Hg on inspiration.[2][3]

Worked example: pulsus paradoxus
  1. Systolic pressure on breathing out: 118 mm Hg
  2. Systolic pressure on breathing in: 102 mm Hg
  3. 118 − 102 = 16 mm Hg
  4. 16 is more than 10, so this is a pulsus paradoxus

Bedside ultrasound clinches it: a pericardial effusion, with collapse of the right atrium or diastolic collapse of the right ventricle.[3][4]

The treatment is to drain the pericardium, and even a small volume removed can raise the blood pressure. In trauma, pericardiocentesis is a temporizing measure and surgery is the more definitive treatment.[2][3][4]

Telling tension pneumothorax from cardiac tamponade at the bedside

Bedside separation of the two causes of obstructive shock
FindingTension pneumothoraxCardiac tamponade
Breath soundsDecreased or absent on one sideEqual
PercussionHyperresonantNot a feature
TracheaShifted away in a large oneNot a feature
Heart soundsNot a featureMuffled
UltrasoundNo pericardial effusionPericardial effusion with right ventricular or atrial collapse
Immediate fixNeedle decompression, then chest tubeDrain the pericardium

In short: one-sided absent breath sounds, hyperresonance and a shifted trachea mean pneumothorax. Equal breath sounds, muffled heart tones and an effusion on ultrasound mean tamponade.[1][4]

A vasopressor alone may raise the pressure but leaves the obstruction in place; relieving the obstruction is what treats obstructive shock.[3][6]

Practice question

Original · USMLE style
Your turnQB-MS-CK-EMER-016-01

A 66-year-old woman is brought to the emergency department because of worsening shortness of breath for 2 days. She has metastatic lung cancer. Temperature is 36.9°C (98.4°F), pulse is 124/min, respirations are 26/min, and blood pressure is 82/54 mm Hg. Oxygen saturation is 93% on room air. She is anxious and diaphoretic. The jugular veins are distended. The trachea is midline. Breath sounds are equal and clear bilaterally, and percussion is resonant bilaterally. Heart sounds are muffled. Systolic blood pressure decreases by 18 mm Hg during inspiration. Bedside ultrasonography shows a large pericardial effusion with diastolic collapse of the right ventricle.

Which of the following is the most appropriate next step in management?
Pick one option. Your answers stay on this device.

Common questions

What is the difference between tension pneumothorax and cardiac tamponade?

Both are obstructive shock and classically cause low blood pressure and distended neck veins. Tension pneumothorax gives one-sided absent breath sounds, hyperresonance and, in a large one, a shifted trachea. Tamponade gives equal breath sounds, muffled heart tones and an effusion on ultrasound.

Do you need a chest x-ray to diagnose tension pneumothorax?

No. Tension pneumothorax is a clinical diagnosis, and you do not wait for a chest x-ray before treating it.

Where is needle decompression done?

In adults, at the fourth or fifth intercostal space, just in front of the midaxillary line. The second intercostal space, midclavicular, is the traditional alternative. A chest tube follows the needle.

What is Beck's triad?

Low blood pressure, muffled heart sounds and raised venous pressure. It is the classic picture of cardiac tamponade, but it is often incomplete, so do not wait for all three.

What is pulsus paradoxus?

A fall in systolic blood pressure of more than 10 mm Hg on inspiration, a second clue to cardiac tamponade.

Transcript

Read the full narration, by chapter722 words

0:00A stabbed man: needle or drain?

A man has been stabbed in the chest, and his blood pressure is 70 over 40. His neck veins are swollen, his heart is racing, and he is heading for cardiac arrest. A needle in the chest wall might save him. So might fluid drained from around the heart. Which one he needs depends on what you find. By the end of this lesson, you'll tell tension pneumothorax from cardiac tamponade at the bedside, and choose the immediate fix for each.

0:27Shared physiology: obstructive shock

Start with the shared physiology. Both are obstructive shock: the heart muscle is fine, but something blocks blood from getting into it or out of it. Cardiac output falls, and because blood is backing up behind the block, venous pressure rises. That's why both classically show low blood pressure and distended neck veins. So the fix is to remove the obstruction.

0:52Tension pneumothorax: the mechanism

First, tension pneumothorax. Air enters the pleural space and can't get out, so pressure inside that side of the chest keeps climbing. The rising pressure squeezes the great veins, and venous return, the preload, falls.

1:08Bedside signs and a clinical diagnosis

At the bedside you find hypotension, decreased or absent breath sounds on the affected side, and a hyperresonant percussion note. In a large one, the trachea shifts away from that side. In a patient on a ventilator, a sudden drop in blood pressure should make you think of it. Here's the key point: tension pneumothorax is a clinical diagnosis. You don't wait for a chest x-ray.

1:33Needle decompression, then chest tube (and the needle site)

You decompress with a large-bore needle, then place a chest tube. In adults, the site is the fourth or fifth intercostal space, just in front of the midaxillary line; the second space, midclavicular, is the traditional alternative. Needle first, tube next.

1:51Cardiac tamponade: fluid in the pericardial sac

Now cardiac tamponade. Fluid collects in the pericardial sac, with enough pressure to stop the heart filling. Speed matters more than volume.

2:01Slow versus fast: about 2 L or about 150 mL

If fluid builds slowly, the pericardium stretches to hold up to about two liters. If it builds fast, as in trauma, about a 150 mL can be enough. The classic clues are Beck's triad:

2:14Beck's triad and pulsus paradoxus

low blood pressure, muffled heart sounds, and raised venous pressure. But the triad is often incomplete, so don't wait for all three. A second clue is pulsus paradoxus, a fall in systolic pressure of more than 10 millimeters of mercury on inspiration. Say a pressure of 118 on breathing out drops to 102 on breathing in: a 16-point fall.

2:42Ultrasound and pericardiocentesis

Bedside ultrasound clinches it: a pericardial effusion, with the right ventricle or right atrium collapsing in diastole. The treatment is to drain the pericardium. Pericardiocentesis is the usual treatment; only in trauma is it a bridge, and even a small volume removed can raise the blood pressure. In trauma, surgery is the more definitive

3:04How to tell them apart

treatment. So here's how to separate them. One-sided absent breath sounds, hyperresonance, and a shifted trachea mean pneumothorax. Equal breath sounds, muffled heart tones, and an effusion on ultrasound mean tamponade.

3:19Practice question

Your turn. Pause if you want to work it out. A 66-year-old woman with metastatic lung cancer has had 2 days of worsening shortness of breath. Her blood pressure is 82 over 54, her pulse is 124, and her neck veins are distended. Breath sounds are equal and clear on both sides, the trachea is midline, and the heart sounds are muffled. Systolic pressure falls by 18 millimeters of mercury when she inhales, and ultrasound shows a large pericardial effusion with right ventricular collapse. What's the most appropriate next step?

3:58Answer and explanation

Needle decompression of the chest is for tension pneumothorax, and her breath sounds and trachea don't fit that. A chest tube drains air or fluid from the pleural space, not the pericardium. Furosemide lowers preload, and this patient's output already depends on filling. Norepinephrine alone raises the pressure, but leaves the obstruction in place. The answer is E: pericardiocentesis. It removes the fluid that's blocking filling,

4:30Recap and next lesson

and it can restore the pressure quickly. Quick recap. One: both are obstructive shock, with low output and distended neck veins, and both need the obstruction removed. Two: tension pneumothorax is a clinical diagnosis, treated with needle decompression and then a chest tube, without waiting for a chest x-ray. Three: tamponade shows muffled heart sounds, pulsus paradoxus and an effusion on ultrasound, and it needs the pericardium drained. Next: the trauma primary survey, and where these two sit in the first minutes.

Sources

Numbers in the text, e.g. [1], point here
  1. Rivera. Pneumothorax. MSD Manual Professional Version (full review July 2025). msdmanuals.com/professional/pulmonary-disorders/mediastinal-and-pleural-disorders/pneumothorax
  2. Forrester. Cardiac Tamponade. MSD Manual Professional Version (full review May 2026). msdmanuals.com/professional/injuries-poisoning/thoracic-trauma/cardiac-tamponade
  3. Zotzmann V, et al. Obstructive shock review. Rev Cardiovasc Med 2022;23(7):248. imrpress.com/journal/RCM/23/7/10.31083/j.rcm2307248
  4. Assaf et al. Traumatic cardiac tamponade, systematic review. Cureus 2025;17(9):e91921. doi.org/10.7759/cureus.91921
  5. Suhaib et al. World J Emerg Surg 2025 (tension pneumothorax). europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC12087068
  6. Chest trauma review (tension pneumothorax and decompression). europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC7223697
  7. Case report, IDCases 2020 (rapid accumulation, about 150 mL). europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC7331566
  8. Medicina 2025 (tamponade, slow versus rapid accumulation). europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC11857578
  9. Tamponade review (Beck triad, raised jugular venous pressure). europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC8246136
  10. Needle site (adults, 4th or 5th intercostal space, just in front of the midaxillary line; 2nd space midclavicular as the traditional alternative): secondary summary of ATLS 10th edition, paramedicpractice.com/articles/needle-decompression-in-tension-pneumothorax-anterior-or-lateral-approach

The pressure-volume graph, the schematic chest wall and the schematic echo on screen are teaching sketches, not data or real images; 118 to 102 mm Hg and the practice-question numbers are synthetic.

The practice question is original and its patient is synthetic. Every fact is checked against the sources above in independent accuracy reviews. Always follow your local guidelines and your own laboratory’s ranges.

Image credits. Illustrations: Servier Medical Art (smart.servier.com), CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), adapted (recoloured, outlined, labelled): "Pneumothorax" (normal and collapsed lung), "Systolic heart failure" (heart), "Pericarditis" (heart with pericardium), "Lying man", "Stethoscope", "Syringe". Echocardiography icon by DBCLS via bioicons.com, CC BY 4.0, adapted. Ventilator and X-ray icons: Health Icons (healthicons.org), CC0. Original diagrams: the pump-block diagram, pressure-volume sketch, schematic chest wall, schematic echo, comparison table and all handwriting are drawn in code. No AI-generated teaching images.

Corrections. None so far. Spotted an error? Email info@medservatory.com with the lesson code MS-CK-EMER-016.

For exam study only, not medical advice. Read the medical disclaimer.

  1. EP 01Types of shock: telling the four patterns apart at the bedside5:07
  2. EP 02Sepsis and septic shock: the first hour in order5:11
  3. EP 03Tension pneumothorax vs cardiac tamponade: obstructive shock5:11
  4. EP 04Trauma primary survey: the xABCDE order5:11
  5. EP 05Acute shortness of breath: the differential and first tests5:08
  6. EP 06Anaphylaxis treatment: recognition and epinephrine first5:29
  7. EP 07Unstable tachycardia: synchronized cardioversion or drugs?5:08
  8. EP 08Bradycardia management: atropine, pacing and AV block types5:04
  9. EP 09Altered mental status workup: the initial six steps5:26
  10. EP 10Acetaminophen overdose: the nomogram, NAPQI and NAC4:57