Advance directives and surrogate decision-makers: who decides?
When a patient cannot decide, work down a ladder: involve the patient as far as possible, then a clear directive, the named agent, then the default surrogate. The surrogate applies substituted judgment first.
Chapters (9)
Apply the hierarchy of advance directives, durable power of attorney and surrogates to end-of-life decisions.
The short version
- An advance directive is what a patient says, while able to decide, about care for a time when they cannot: a living will, a durable power of attorney for health care, or both.
- Directives do nothing while the patient has capacity; once capacity is lost, work down the ladder: involve the patient as far as possible, then a clear directive, the named agent, then the default surrogate.
- In most states the default surrogate order is spouse, adult child, parent, adult sibling.
- Surrogates use substituted judgment first, then best interest; the surrogate's own preferences do not decide.
- Withholding and withdrawing a treatment are ethically equivalent; unresolved disagreement goes to the ethics committee.
What an advance directive is: living will and durable power of attorney
An advance directive is what a patient says, while still able to decide, about care for a time when they cannot. It takes two forms.[1][2]
| Document | What it does |
|---|---|
| Living will | States which treatments the patient would accept or refuse, such as ventilation, dialysis or resuscitation |
| Durable power of attorney for health care | Names a person, the agent or proxy, to decide for the patient |
Advance directives and surrogate decision-makers fit together: the directive records the patient's wishes, and the agent or surrogate applies them when the patient cannot speak.[1][3]
When a directive applies: only once capacity is lost
Neither document does anything while the patient can decide. A patient with capacity decides for themselves, and can change or revoke a directive.[1][4][6]
A directive matters only after capacity is lost. At that point, the question becomes who speaks for the patient and in what order.[3]
The decision ladder when a patient cannot decide
Once capacity is lost, work down a ladder, one rung at a time and in order.[3]
- Involve the patient as far as possibleEven a patient who lacks capacity should take part as far as possible, and anything they can still express informs the decision. It does not by itself override a clear directive or the named agent.
- A clear directive that fits the situationIt guides every decision after it.
- The agent named in the durable power of attorneyThe agent decides what the patient would want, using the directive and everything else known.
- The default surrogate under state lawThis applies if the patient named nobody.
The agent therefore outranks the default family order. The default list is a fallback for patients who named no agent.[3][6]
The default surrogate order
Where the patient named nobody, state law supplies the surrogate. In most states the order runs: spouse, adult child, parent, adult sibling.[7]
- Spouse
- Adult child
- Parent
- Adult sibling
Substituted judgment, then best interest
Whoever is deciding, two standards apply, in order.[3][4]
| Standard | What it asks | Based on |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Substituted judgment | Decide as the patient would | The directive, the chart and what the patient valued |
| 2. Best interest | Weigh the factors below | Suffering, benefit, impairment and quality of life |
Substituted judgment asks what the patient would decide. It draws on the directive, the chart and what the patient valued.[3][4]
Best interest is used only when the patient's wishes cannot be known or inferred. The surrogate's own preferences do not decide.[3]
Back to the case that opens the lesson: a woman in her eighties is unconscious after a stroke, her living will says no feeding tube, and her husband at the bedside says do everything. The husband cannot override the living will. His role is to say what his wife would want.[3]
Withholding versus withdrawing, and when to consult the ethics committee
Withholding and withdrawing a treatment are ethically equivalent, so stopping a ventilator is no worse than never starting it.[4][8]
When surrogates or the team disagree and cannot resolve it, or a surrogate's choice clearly contradicts what the patient would have wanted, consult the ethics committee.[3][4]
The ethics committee supports the team and the surrogate; it does not replace the ladder. The ladder still decides whose voice counts, and the committee is consulted when disagreement cannot be resolved or a surrogate's choice clearly contradicts the patient's wishes.[3][4]
Worked example: no directive, no agent
A 59-year-old man collapses. He has no directive and named no agent. His wife and three grown sons are in the waiting room.
- No directive and no agent, so the default order applies.
- His wife decides first.
- The team asks her what he would choose, not what she would.
- If she cannot be reached, his sons are next.
The wife decides first because the patient left no directive and named no agent, so the default order applies. She still decides by substituted judgment, as the patient would, not by her own preferences.[3][7]
Practice question
Original · USMLE styleA 74-year-old man with metastatic pancreatic cancer is brought to the emergency department with fever, a respiratory rate of 34/min and an oxygen saturation of 82% on a non-rebreather mask. He is unresponsive. Chest imaging shows a right lower lobe pneumonia. The team determines that he needs intubation and mechanical ventilation to survive the next several hours. His medical record contains a signed durable power of attorney for health care naming his daughter as his agent. A note from an oncology visit 2 months ago records that he told his oncologist he would not want to be placed on a ventilator, even temporarily. His daughter, reached by telephone, states that he would refuse intubation. His wife, who is at the bedside, insists that "everything possible" be done.
Common questions
What is the difference between a living will and a durable power of attorney for health care?
A living will states which treatments the patient would accept or refuse. A durable power of attorney for health care names a person, the agent or proxy, to decide for the patient.
Who decides if a patient has no advance directive and named no agent?
The default surrogate under state law decides. In most states the order is spouse, adult child, parent, adult sibling.
What is the difference between substituted judgment and best interest?
Substituted judgment means deciding as the patient would, using the directive, the chart and what they valued. Best interest is used only when the patient's wishes cannot be known or inferred, and weighs suffering, benefit, impairment and quality of life.
Is withdrawing life-sustaining treatment different from withholding it?
No. The two are ethically equivalent, so stopping a ventilator is no worse than never starting it.
When should the ethics committee be consulted?
When surrogates or the team disagree and cannot resolve it, or when a surrogate's choice clearly contradicts what the patient would have wanted.
Transcript
Read the full narration, by chapter677 words
0:00The case: a living will says no feeding tube, the husband says do everything
A woman in her eighties is unconscious after a stroke. Her living will says no feeding tube. Her husband, at the bedside, says: do everything. Whose voice counts? Today: rank the sources of authority for a patient who cannot decide, and apply them in order.
0:18What an advance directive is: living will and durable power of attorney
An advance directive is what a patient says, while still able to decide, about care for a time when they cannot. A living will states which treatments the patient would accept or refuse, such as ventilation, dialysis or resuscitation. A durable power of attorney for health care names a person, the agent or proxy, to decide for them. Neither document does anything while the patient can decide: a patient with capacity decides for themselves, and can change or revoke a directive.
0:50The ladder: patient's voice, directive, agent, default surrogate
Once capacity is lost, work down a ladder. First, anything the patient can still express, because even an impaired patient should take part as far as possible. Second, a clear directive that fits the situation. It guides every decision after it. Third, the agent named in the durable power of attorney, who decides what the patient would want, using the directive and everything else known. Fourth, if the patient named nobody, the default surrogate under state law. In most states that order runs: spouse, adult child, parent, adult sibling.
1:30Two standards: substituted judgment, then best interest
Whoever is deciding, two standards apply, in order. First, substituted judgment: decide as the patient would, using the directive, the chart, and what they valued. Only when their wishes cannot be known or inferred do we use best interest: weigh suffering, benefit, impairment and quality of life. So the surrogate's own preferences do not decide. Back to our patient: her husband cannot override her living will. His role is to say what she would want.
2:03Withholding vs withdrawing, and the ethics committee
Two more points. Withholding and withdrawing a treatment are ethically equivalent, so stopping a ventilator is no worse than never starting it. And when surrogates disagree, or a surrogate's choice clearly contradicts what the patient would have wanted, consult the ethics committee.
2:21Worked example: no directive, no agent
Now apply the ladder. A 59-year-old man collapses. He has no directive and named no agent. His wife and three grown sons are in the waiting room. With no directive and no agent, the default order applies, so his wife decides first. The team asks her what he would choose, not what she would. If she cannot be reached, his sons are next.
2:47Your turn: practice question
Your turn. A 74-year-old man with metastatic pancreatic cancer arrives with fever and respiratory failure, and he is unresponsive. He needs intubation to survive the next hours. His chart holds a signed durable power of attorney naming his daughter as agent. An oncology note from two months ago records that he would not want a ventilator, even temporarily. His daughter, on the phone, says he would refuse intubation. His wife, at the bedside, insists on everything possible. Which of the following is the most appropriate next step? A, intubate, because a spouse takes priority over an adult child. B, petition the court to appoint a guardian to decide for him. C, intubate temporarily until the hospital ethics committee has reviewed the case. D, withhold intubation, following the decision of the daughter he appointed. E, require the wife and daughter to agree before acting. Pause here and decide.
3:54The answer: wrong options first
A is out: the spouse leads only the default list, and that list applies when the patient named no agent. B is out: a guardian is for patients with no designated surrogate, and he named one. C is out: an ethics consultation can support the wife, but temporary intubation is exactly what he refused. E is out: the agent decides, and the wife's agreement is not a condition. So the answer is D. His agent, applying substituted judgment, speaks for him, and her decision matches the wishes he recorded.
4:31Recap and next lesson
Three things to keep. One: the ladder runs from the patient's own voice to a clear directive, then the named agent, then the default surrogate. Two: surrogates use substituted judgment first, then best interest. Three: unresolved disagreement goes to the ethics committee. Next, disclosing medical errors.
Sources
Numbers in the text, e.g. [1], point here- AMA Code of Medical Ethics, Opinion 5.1 Advance Care Planning. code-medical-ethics.ama-assn.org/ethics-opinions/advance-care-planning
- Europe PMC PMC13157551 (advance directives). europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC13157551
- AMA Code of Medical Ethics, Opinion 2.1.2 Decisions for Adult Patients Who Lack Capacity. code-medical-ethics.ama-assn.org/ethics-opinions/decisions-adult-patients-who-lack-capacity
- AMA Code of Medical Ethics, Opinion 5.3 Withholding or Withdrawing Life-Sustaining Treatment. code-medical-ethics.ama-assn.org/ethics-opinions/withholding-or-withdrawing-life-sustaining-treatment
- Europe PMC PMC13169564, surrogate decision-making framework (proposed design study). europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC13169564
- Europe PMC PMC9790446, guardianship review, J Am Geriatr Soc 2022. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC9790446
- American Geriatrics Society position statement on surrogate decision-making, J Am Geriatr Soc 2025. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC12100688
- Europe PMC PMC13562335, Eur Geriatr Med 2026, withholding and withdrawing life-sustaining treatment. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC13562335
Guideline basis: the lesson follows the AMA Code of Medical Ethics (Opinions 2.1.2, 5.1 and 5.3), read on 13 Nov 2026. This is the exam-standard US framework; the default surrogate order varies by state, and a UK (PLAB) version will follow separately.
The practice question is original and its patient is synthetic. Every fact is checked against the sources above in independent accuracy reviews. Always follow your local guidelines and your own laboratory’s ranges.
Image credits. Illustrations: Servier Medical Art (smart.servier.com), CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), adapted (recoloured, outlined, resized; badge removed and shirt colour changed on the young-man figure): elderly man, elderly woman, adult man, adult woman, young man. Icons: Health Icons (healthicons.org), CC0 1.0 (no credit required), recoloured and resized: hospital bed, ventilator, dialysis, CPR, person, group discussion, phone. The living-will form, power-of-attorney form, ladder, standards cards, timeline, question card, pocket card and all handwriting are drawn in code (original). No AI-generated teaching images.
Corrections. None so far. Spotted an error? Email info@medservatory.com with the lesson code MS-CK-ETH-004.
For exam study only, not medical advice. Read the medical disclaimer.
In this series
Playlist on YouTube- EP 01Informed consent and decision-making capacity: the four abilities5:15
- EP 02Confidentiality exceptions: when you may or must disclose5:03
- EP 03Minors and consent: when a child can decide and when parents cannot4:50
- EP 04Advance directives and surrogate decision-makers: who decides?4:57
- EP 05Disclosing medical errors: disclose, apologize, report4:39
- EP 06Medical interpreter and teach-back: language and health literacy5:04