USMLE Step 2 CKEthics, law and patient safetyEP 01 of 06

Informed consent and decision-making capacity: the four abilities

A signature is not the same as informed consent. Learn the three elements of valid consent, the four abilities that make up capacity, and what to do when capacity is in doubt.

  • 5:15 video
  • 3 min read
  • 10 sources
  • Published 17 Nov 2026
Chapters (12)
By the end of this lesson

Identify the elements of informed consent and of decision-making capacity, and choose the next step when capacity is uncertain.

The short version

  1. Informed consent is a process, not a signature: it needs disclosure, capacity and voluntariness.
  2. Capacity means the ability to choose, understand, appreciate and reason, judged for this particular decision.
  3. An unwise choice is not the same as incapacity; a patient with capacity may refuse, and the refusal is respected.
  4. When capacity is uncertain, assess it before you use a surrogate, and treat reversible causes.
  5. A surrogate decides only if the patient lacks capacity: first the named person, otherwise family, using substituted judgment and then best interest.

Informed consent: does the signature count?

A 58-year-old woman signs the consent form for her operation. Asked what the operation is for, she cannot tell you. Does her signature count?

This lesson covers informed consent: its three required elements, the four abilities that make up decision-making capacity, and what to do when capacity is uncertain. Informed consent is a process, not a signature.[1][5]

Three things must be present for consent to be valid: disclosure, capacity and voluntariness.[1][5]

Elements of valid informed consent
ElementWhat it means
DisclosureYou explain the diagnosis, the purpose of the treatment, its risks and benefits, and the alternatives, including doing nothing.
CapacityThe patient's ability to make this particular decision.
VoluntarinessThe choice is free of coercion and pressure.

You also document the conversation and the decision in the record.[1][5]

Decision-making capacity and its four abilities

Adults are presumed to have capacity unless something suggests otherwise.[5]

Capacity has four abilities. A clear failure of any one of them can mean the patient lacks capacity for that decision.[3][4][6]

The four abilities of decision-making capacity
AbilityWhat the patient can do
Express a choiceState a decision
UnderstandTake in the information given
AppreciateSee how the information applies to their own situation
ReasonWeigh the options and explain how they decided

Worked example: refusing amputation, and failing to appreciate

A 66-year-old woman has a gangrenous diabetic foot, and the surgeons advise amputation. She says that without surgery the infection can spread and she could die, but she would still rather keep her foot. She chooses, understands, appreciates and reasons.

She has capacity. A choice you think unwise is not the same as incapacity, so you respect her refusal.[3][5]

A second patient says: "There is nothing wrong with my foot." She cannot appreciate that the information applies to her. That is a failure of appreciation, but only when the false belief is clearly unrealistic and comes from impaired cognition or mood, not from her values.[3][6]

Back to the 58-year-old woman from the opening: her signature proves nothing unless she understood. If she cannot grasp the information, either disclosure or capacity has failed, and the consent is not valid.[1][3]

Capacity is decision-specific and can fluctuate

Capacity is specific to the decision, and it can fluctuate.[3][4]

Delirium, infection, medications and drowsiness can all change it. Treat the reversible causes, then reassess.[4]

When capacity is uncertain: assess it, then consider a surrogate

When capacity is uncertain, do not guess, and do not simply hand the decision to the family. Assess it.[1][2][3]

  1. Ask the patient to explainIn their own words: the condition, the treatment, the alternatives, what follows from each choice, and how they decided.[3]
  2. Treat reversible causesThen reassess.[4]
  3. Decide the pathIf the patient has capacity, honor the decision. If the patient lacks capacity for that decision, turn to a surrogate.[2][5][7]

The first choice of surrogate is the person the patient named, for example in a durable power of attorney for health care. Otherwise, a family member or close associate.[2][7][8]

The surrogate uses substituted judgment: what the patient would have wanted. If that is unknown, the surrogate uses best interest.[2][8]

The emergency exception to consent

The exception is a true emergency: the decision is urgent, the patient cannot take part, and no surrogate is available. Treat, then inform the patient or surrogate at the earliest opportunity.[1][10]

Practice question

Original · USMLE style
Your turnQB-MS-CK-ETH-001-01

A 79-year-old man is hospitalized with community-acquired pneumonia. On hospital day 2, he refuses intravenous antibiotics and asks to go home. Last night, nursing staff documented that he was disoriented and pulling at his IV line. This morning he is awake and attentive. He says he has "just a chest cold that will clear up by itself." Temperature is 38.1 C (100.6 F), pulse is 92/min, respirations are 18/min, blood pressure is 134/80 mm Hg, and oxygen saturation is 94% on room air. He has no health care proxy or advance directive. His wife, with whom he lives, is at home.

Which of the following is the most appropriate next step?
Pick one option. Your answers stay on this device.

Common questions

What are the elements of informed consent?

Disclosure, capacity and voluntariness. Disclosure covers the diagnosis, the purpose of the treatment, its risks and benefits, and the alternatives, including doing nothing; the conversation and decision are documented in the record.

What are the four abilities of decision-making capacity?

Expressing a choice, understanding the information, appreciating how it applies to oneself, and reasoning about the options. Capacity is judged for the particular decision.

Can a patient with capacity refuse treatment?

Yes. A choice you think unwise is not the same as incapacity, so the refusal is respected.

Who decides if a patient lacks capacity?

A surrogate: first the person the patient named, for example in a durable power of attorney for health care, otherwise a family member or close associate. The surrogate uses substituted judgment, and best interest if the patient's wishes are unknown.

When does the emergency exception to consent apply?

When the decision is urgent, the patient cannot take part and no surrogate is available. Treat, then inform the patient or surrogate at the earliest opportunity.

Transcript

Read the full narration, by chapter701 words

0:00The case: she signed, but can she say what the operation is for?

A 58-year-old woman signs the consent form for her operation. But when you ask her what the operation is for, she cannot tell you. Does her signature count? Today: the elements of informed consent, the four abilities of capacity, and what to do when capacity is uncertain.

0:18Informed consent: disclosure, capacity, voluntariness, and documentation

Informed consent is a process, not a signature. Three things must be present: disclosure, capacity, and voluntariness. Disclosure means you explain the diagnosis, the purpose of the treatment, its risks and benefits, and the alternatives, including doing nothing. Voluntariness means the choice is free of coercion and pressure. And you document the conversation and the decision in the record.

0:46Capacity: the patient's ability to make this decision, and its four abilities

That leaves capacity: the patient's ability to make this particular decision. Adults are presumed to have it, unless something suggests otherwise. Capacity has four abilities: express a choice, understand the information, appreciate how it applies to you, and reason about the options.

1:05Worked example: a patient who refuses amputation and a patient who cannot appreciate

Take a 66-year-old woman with a gangrenous diabetic foot. The surgeons advise amputation. She says: "Without surgery the infection can spread and I could die. I would still rather keep my foot." She chooses, understands, appreciates and reasons. She has capacity. A choice you think unwise is not the same as incapacity, so you respect her refusal. Now a second patient says: "There is nothing wrong with my foot." She cannot appreciate that the information applies to her. That is a failure of appreciation, but only when the false belief comes from impaired cognition or mood, not from her values. Back to our first patient.

1:50Back to the first patient: a signature proves nothing unless she understood

The signature proves nothing unless she understood. If she cannot grasp the information, either disclosure or capacity has failed, and the consent is not valid.

2:03Two cautions: capacity is decision-specific and can fluctuate

Two cautions. Capacity is specific to the decision, and it can fluctuate. Delirium, infection, medications and drowsiness can all change it. Treat the reversible causes, then reassess. So when capacity is uncertain,

2:18When capacity is uncertain: assess it, do not guess

do not guess, and do not simply hand the decision to the family. Assess it. Ask the patient to explain, in their own words, the condition, the treatment, the alternatives, what follows from each choice, and how they decided. If the patient lacks capacity for that decision,

2:37Surrogates: named proxy, family, substituted judgment, best interest

turn to a surrogate. First choice is the person the patient named, for example in a durable power of attorney for health care. Otherwise, a family member or close associate. The surrogate uses substituted judgment, what the patient would have wanted. If that is unknown, the surrogate uses best interest.

2:59The emergency exception

The exception is a true emergency: the decision is urgent, the patient cannot take part, and no surrogate is available. Treat, then inform the patient or surrogate at the earliest opportunity.

3:12Your turn: practice question

Your turn. A 79-year-old man is in hospital with pneumonia. On day two he refuses intravenous antibiotics and asks to go home. Last night he was disoriented and pulling at his drip. This morning he is awake and attentive, and says it is only a chest cold that will clear by itself. His temperature is 38.1 degrees Celsius, and he is stable. He has no health care proxy. His wife is at home. What is the most appropriate next step? A, obtain consent for antibiotics from his wife. B, treat him under the emergency exception to consent. C, discharge him home in accordance with his wishes. D, evaluate his capacity for this decision. E, petition a court to appoint a guardian. Pause here and decide.

4:09The answer: wrong options first

A is out: a surrogate decides only after the patient is found to lack capacity, and nobody has assessed that yet. B is out: the emergency exception needs an urgent threat and no chance to ask. He is stable, so there is time to assess him. C is out: honoring a refusal presumes capacity, and his fluctuating confusion raises real doubt. E is out: guardianship is a slow court process for lasting incapacity, not the first step. So the answer is D. His capacity may fluctuate, and he is calm now: assess it, and treat the reversible causes. Three things to keep.

4:50Recap

One: informed consent needs disclosure, capacity and voluntariness. Two: capacity means choice, understanding, appreciation and reasoning, for this decision. Three: if capacity is uncertain, assess it before you use a surrogate. Next, confidentiality and its exceptions.

Sources

Numbers in the text, e.g. [1], point here
  1. American Medical Association. Code of Medical Ethics, Opinion 2.1.1 Informed Consent. code-medical-ethics.ama-assn.org
  2. American Medical Association. Code of Medical Ethics, Opinion 2.1.2 Decisions for Adult Patients Who Lack Capacity. code-medical-ethics.ama-assn.org
  3. Owen GS, et al. Decision-making capacity (four-abilities model, MacCAT-T). Br J Psychiatry 2013. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC3844898
  4. Capacity issues and decision-making in dementia. Ann Indian Acad Neurol 2016. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC5109759
  5. Core concepts of consent in medical practice. Singapore Med J 2023. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC10335635
  6. Emotion and value in the evaluation of medical decision-making capacity. Front Psychol 2016. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC4880567
  7. Guardianship: a medicolegal review for clinicians. J Am Geriatr Soc 2022. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC9790446
  8. How should treatment decisions be made for incapacitated patients, and why? PLoS Med 2007. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC1820603
  9. UBACC capacity questionnaire study. BMJ Open 2026. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC13662082
  10. Informed consent process for emergency surgery. SAGE Open Med 2023. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC10285587

Guideline basis: the lesson follows the AMA Code of Medical Ethics, Opinion 2.1.1 (Informed Consent) and Opinion 2.1.2 (Decisions for Adult Patients Who Lack Capacity), read on 13 Nov 2026, with the peer-reviewed capacity literature below. This is the exam-standard US framework; US law varies by state, and a UK (PLAB) version will follow separately.

The practice question is original and its patient is synthetic. Every fact is checked against the sources above in independent accuracy reviews. Always follow your local guidelines and your own laboratory’s ranges.

Image credits. Icons (woman, doctor, discussion, ambulance, health worker, documents accepted, documents denied, justice scales): Health Icons (healthicons.org), CC0 1.0 (no credit required), recoloured and resized. The consent form, speech and thought bubbles, pillars, ability checklist, capacity-over-time chart, surrogate ladder, question card, pocket card and all handwriting are drawn in code (original). The capacity-over-time chart is a schematic, not measured data. No AI-generated teaching images.

Corrections. None so far. Spotted an error? Email info@medservatory.com with the lesson code MS-CK-ETH-001.

For exam study only, not medical advice. Read the medical disclaimer.

  1. EP 01Informed consent and decision-making capacity: the four abilities5:15
  2. EP 02Confidentiality exceptions: when you may or must disclose5:03
  3. EP 03Minors and consent: when a child can decide and when parents cannot4:50
  4. EP 04Advance directives and surrogate decision-makers: who decides?4:57
  5. EP 05Disclosing medical errors: disclose, apologize, report4:39
  6. EP 06Medical interpreter and teach-back: language and health literacy5:04