Confidentiality exceptions: when you may or must disclose
Confidentiality is the default, and the patient decides who is told. The exceptions fall into two groups: the law requires disclosure, or someone else faces serious danger.
Chapters (11)
Identify when confidentiality may or must be broken (serious threat to others, reportable diseases, abuse) in US practice.
The short version
- Information gathered during care is confidential; outside the care team, disclosure needs the patient's consent unless an exception applies.
- Confidentiality exceptions come in two groups: disclosure the law requires, and serious danger to others.
- Reportable infectious diseases and suspected child abuse must be reported; the standard for abuse is reasonable suspicion, not proof.
- Tarasoff: a serious threat of violence against an identifiable victim creates a duty to protect, met by warning, notifying police or other reasonable steps.
- Disclose only the minimum necessary and, when feasible, tell the patient; an anxious relative or an employer is not an exception.
The case: who can be told what?
A 30-year-old man has active tuberculosis, and he begs you not to tell anyone. His employer keeps calling. His sister keeps calling. The health department is waiting for a report.
This lesson covers confidentiality exceptions in United States practice: when confidentiality may or must be broken, and who still gets nothing without the patient's consent. State law varies, so the lesson teaches the exam-standard framework.[2][7]
The default: confidentiality, and consent for everyone else
Information gathered during care stays confidential, and the patient decides who receives it.[1]
Sharing with the care team for treatment is fine.[1][2] Anything else, including family and employers, needs the patient's consent.[1]
The exceptions come in two groups: the law requires disclosure, or someone else faces serious danger.[1][2]
Exceptions the law requires: reportable diseases and abuse
Reporting statutes override the patient's wishes.[1][2]
| Situation | What the rule says |
|---|---|
| Reportable infectious diseases | Report to the public health department. Tuberculosis and certain sexually transmitted infections, such as syphilis, gonorrhea and chlamydia, are classic examples; each state keeps its own list.[3][4][5] |
| Child abuse | Every state requires physicians to report suspected child abuse. The standard is reasonable suspicion: no proof is needed. A good-faith report is a defense against a civil suit for breaching confidentiality.[3][4] |
| Elder abuse | Reporting is required or permitted depending on the state.[2][6] |
| Gunshot wounds | Many states require reporting.[2] |
Back to the opening case: you report the tuberculosis to the health department. You do not tell his employer or his sister.[1][4]
HIPAA fits this picture. It permits disclosures the law requires, public health reporting, and reports of abuse.[2][3]
Danger to others: the Tarasoff duty to protect
Picture a man who tells his psychiatrist he is going to shoot his former employer, and he names him.
In 1976, the California Supreme Court decided Tarasoff: a therapist has a duty to protect a person at risk from a patient. The court wrote, "The protective privilege ends where the public peril begins."[7][8]
- Trigger: a serious threat of violence against an identifiable victim.[7][8]
- How to meet the duty: warn the victim, notify the police, or take other reasonable steps to protect him.[7][8]
States differ: some make the duty mandatory, others only permit disclosure. The AMA says a physician may disclose when there is a reasonable probability of serious physical harm to an identifiable person.[1][7]
Minimum necessary, and what is not an exception
Whatever the reason for disclosure, the AMA advises sharing only the minimum necessary information, and telling the patient about the disclosure when that is feasible.[1]
Putting it together: a decision path
- Does the law require a report?Reportable infectious disease or suspected abuse: report; the AMA advises sharing only what is needed.[1][3][4]
- Is there a serious threat to an identifiable person?If so, the duty to protect may apply: warn the victim, notify the police or take other reasonable steps.[7]
- Neither?Confidentiality holds, and anyone outside the care team needs the patient's consent.[1]
Practice question
Original · USMLE styleA 2-year-old boy is brought to the emergency department by his father because the child will not bear weight on his left leg. The father says the boy fell off a couch this morning. The child is quiet and withdrawn. Examination shows bruises over the back and buttocks in different stages of healing. A radiograph shows a spiral fracture of the left femoral shaft. When you mention contacting child protective services, the father becomes angry and asks you to keep the matter between the two of you.
Common questions
When can confidentiality be broken?
In two groups of situations: when the law requires disclosure, such as reportable infectious diseases and suspected abuse, and when someone else faces serious danger. Otherwise the patient's consent is needed.
What is the Tarasoff duty to protect?
In Tarasoff, decided by the California Supreme Court in 1976, a therapist has a duty to protect a person at risk from a patient. It is triggered by a serious threat of violence against an identifiable victim.
What is the standard for reporting child abuse?
Reasonable suspicion. No proof is needed, and a good-faith report is a defense against a civil suit for breaching confidentiality.
Can you tell a patient's employer or family about a diagnosis?
Not without the patient's consent. An anxious relative, an employer or a curious colleague is not an exception to confidentiality.
Does HIPAA allow these disclosures?
Yes. HIPAA permits disclosures the law requires, public health reporting, and reports of abuse.
Transcript
Read the full narration, by chapter679 words
0:00The case: who can be told what?
A 30-year-old man has active tuberculosis, and he begs you not to tell anyone. His employer keeps calling. His sister keeps calling. And the health department is waiting for a report. Who can be told what? Today: when confidentiality may or must be broken, in United States practice.
0:21The default: confidentiality, and consent for everyone else
The default is simple. Information gathered during care stays confidential, and the patient decides who receives it. Sharing with the care team for treatment is fine. Anything else, including family and employers, needs the patient's consent.
0:38Two groups of exceptions, then disclosures the law requires: reportable infectious diseases
The exceptions come in two groups: the law requires disclosure, or someone else faces serious danger. First, disclosures the law requires. Reporting statutes override the patient's wishes. Reportable infectious diseases go to the public health department. Tuberculosis and certain sexually transmitted infections, such as syphilis, gonorrhea and chlamydia, are classic examples, and each state keeps its own list. So your patient with tuberculosis: you report to the health department. You do not tell his employer or his sister.
1:15Child abuse, elder abuse and gunshot wounds
Child abuse is the next one. Every state requires physicians to report suspected child abuse. The standard is reasonable suspicion. You do not need proof, and a good-faith report is a defense against a civil suit for breaching confidentiality. For elder abuse, reporting is required or permitted depending on the state. Many states also require reporting of gunshot wounds.
1:42Danger to others: the Tarasoff duty to protect
The second group is danger to others. Picture a man who tells his psychiatrist he is going to shoot his former employer, and he names him. In 95, the California Supreme Court decided Tarasoff: a therapist has a duty to protect a person at risk from a patient. The court wrote, "The protective privilege ends where the public peril begins." The trigger is a serious threat of violence against an identifiable victim. You can meet the duty by warning the victim, notifying the police, or taking other reasonable steps to protect him.
2:18States differ, and the AMA wording
States differ: some make the duty mandatory, others only permit disclosure. The AMA says a physician may disclose when there is a reasonable probability of serious physical harm to an identifiable person.
2:33Minimum necessary, and HIPAA
Whatever the reason, the AMA advises sharing only the minimum necessary, and telling the patient about the disclosure when that is feasible. HIPAA fits this picture: it permits disclosures the law requires, public health reporting, and reports of abuse.
2:51What is not an exception
Notice what is not an exception: an anxious relative, an employer, a curious colleague. Without the patient's consent, they get nothing from you.
3:02Your turn: practice question
Your turn. A 2-year-old boy is brought to the emergency department by his father, who says he fell off the couch this morning. The boy will not use his left leg. He is withdrawn, with bruises on his back and buttocks in different stages of healing. An X-ray shows a spiral fracture of the left thigh bone. When you mention child protective services, the father becomes angry and asks you to keep this between the two of you. What is the most appropriate action? A, ask the father for permission to contact child protective services. B, report the suspected abuse to child protective services. C, wait for confirmation of abuse before making a report. D, keep the information confidential and arrange outpatient follow-up. E, request a court order to disclose the information. Pause here and decide.
3:59The answer: wrong options first
A is out: a mandatory report does not depend on the parent's permission, and the parent may be the suspect. C is out: the standard is reasonable suspicion, not proof, and waiting leaves the child exposed. D is out: the duty of confidentiality yields to a legal reporting requirement. E is out: no court order is needed, because the reporting statute already requires the report. So the answer is B. Report your reasonable suspicion of child abuse to child protective services, and share only what is needed.
4:36Recap and next lesson
Three things to keep. One: confidentiality is the default, and without consent the answer is no. Two: the law can require disclosure, as in reportable diseases and suspected abuse. Three: a serious threat to an identifiable person can justify a warning, with the minimum necessary. Next, minors and consent.
Sources
Numbers in the text, e.g. [1], point here- American Medical Association. Code of Medical Ethics, Opinion 3.2.1 Confidentiality. code-medical-ethics.ama-assn.org/ethics-opinions/confidentiality
- Privacy and confidentiality in emergency medicine: obligations and challenges. Emerg Med Clin North Am 2006. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7132767
- Legal concerns in psychosomatic medicine. Psychiatr Clin North Am 2007. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7103291
- Open-access review on confidentiality and mandatory reporting of infectious disease and child abuse. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7132445
- Workowski KA, et al. Sexually Transmitted Infections Treatment Guidelines, 2021. MMWR Recomm Rep 70(4). pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8344968
- Mandatory and permissive reporting laws, 2020. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7493571
- Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California, 17 Cal.3d 425 (1976), as discussed in: Behav Sci Law 2022 · Niger Med J 2023 · West J Emerg Med 2013 pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9540889 · pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11223015 · pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3789925
- Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tarasoff_v._Regents_of_the_University_of_California
Guideline basis: AMA Code of Medical Ethics Opinion 3.2.1 Confidentiality, read 13 Nov 2026, plus US state law and HIPAA as summarised in the open-access reviews below. This is the exam-standard US framework; state law varies.
The practice question is original and its patient is synthetic. Every fact is checked against the sources above in independent accuracy reviews. Always follow your local guidelines and your own laboratory’s ranges.
Image credits. Icons (man, tuberculosis, phone, ministry of health, health worker, discussion, child, documents accepted, doctor, police officer, X-ray, justice scales): Health Icons (healthicons.org), CC0 1.0 (no credit required), recoloured and resized. The confidentiality circle with its gates, the report form, speech bubbles, padlock, shield, state-variation strip, AMA wording card, question card, pocket card and all handwriting are drawn in code (original). No AI-generated teaching images.
Corrections. None so far. Spotted an error? Email info@medservatory.com with the lesson code MS-CK-ETH-002.
For exam study only, not medical advice. Read the medical disclaimer.
In this series
Playlist on YouTube- EP 01Informed consent and decision-making capacity: the four abilities5:15
- EP 02Confidentiality exceptions: when you may or must disclose5:03
- EP 03Minors and consent: when a child can decide and when parents cannot4:50
- EP 04Advance directives and surrogate decision-makers: who decides?4:57
- EP 05Disclosing medical errors: disclose, apologize, report4:39
- EP 06Medical interpreter and teach-back: language and health literacy5:04