USMLE Step 2 CKEthics, law and patient safetyEP 05 of 06

Disclosing medical errors: disclose, apologize, report

An error does not have to cause harm to be disclosed. It only has to be able to. This lesson covers who tells the patient, what to say, and what goes to the system.

  • 4:39 video
  • 3 min read
  • 7 sources
  • Published 17 Nov 2026
Chapters (9)
By the end of this lesson

Choose the appropriate response to a medical error, including disclosure, apology and system reporting.

The short version

  1. An error is anything that harms or could harm a patient, so disclose even when no harm followed.
  2. The physician involved discloses promptly, apologizes, explains the plan to prevent a repeat, and keeps caring for the patient.
  3. Concern about liability must not change a physician's honesty.
  4. Report errors, including those that caused no harm, through the hospital's confidential reporting channel; the purpose is root causes and prevention, not punishment.
  5. If the error was a colleague's, encourage them to disclose it, and report a colleague who is impaired or incompetent.

Do you tell the patient? Disclosing medical errors

You order an antibiotic for a patient, and she is given it although she is allergic. Nothing happens: no rash, no drop in blood pressure, and nobody noticed except you. Do you tell her?

This lesson is about disclosing medical errors. The answer is yes, and the response has three parts: tell the patient, apologize, and report to the system.[1]

What counts as a medical error: harm or potential harm

The AMA Code of Medical Ethics defines an error as an unintended act or omission, or a flawed system or plan, that harms or could harm a patient.[1]

So an error does not have to cause harm. It only has to be able to. That is why the antibiotic given despite an allergy is an error even though nothing happened.[1][5]

Patients have a right to know about their care, including conditions that resulted from an error. And worry about liability must not change a physician's honesty.[1]

Duty 1: disclose promptly, even when treatment will not change

The physician involved tells the patient, and does it promptly.[1][5][6]

  • What happened.
  • What harm it may cause.
  • What the patient needs to know to make later decisions.

That applies even when the new information will not change the treatment.[1]

Duty 2: acknowledge the error and apologize

Acknowledge the error and express real concern.[1] Patients want a plain statement that an error happened, an explanation, the steps to prevent a repeat, and an apology.[3][5]

Keep caring for a patient who was harmed, including helping them move to another physician if trust is lost.[1]

Duty 3: report to the system, and what to do about a colleague's error

Report the error through the hospital's confidential reporting channel, even when nobody was harmed. The purpose is to study root causes and prevent the next error, not to punish.[1][7]

If the error was a colleague's, encourage them to disclose it. And report a colleague who is impaired or incompetent.[1][2]

The three duties at a glance
DutyWhat it involves
DiscloseThe physician involved tells the patient promptly: what happened, what harm it may cause, what is needed for later decisions
ApologizeAcknowledge the error, express concern, explain the steps to prevent a repeat, keep caring for the patient
ReportConfidential reporting channel, even without harm; root causes, not punishment

Worked example: a missed antibiotic dose found a day later

Apply the three duties
  1. A morning antibiotic order never reaches the pharmacy, so one dose is missed.
  2. A colleague notices the next day. The infection is already improving and she has no new symptoms.
  3. Do you disclose? Yes: the omission is an error even though no harm followed, and learning of it late is no reason to stay silent.
  4. The physician responsible for her care sits down with her, explains what happened, apologizes, describes the change that stops it recurring, and files the report.

The same applies to the allergy case at the start: you tell her.[1][3]

Practice question

Original · USMLE style
Your turnQB-MS-CK-ETH-005-01

A 64-year-old man without diabetes is recovering on the orthopedic ward after an elective knee replacement. At 8:00 PM he receives a subcutaneous dose of insulin that was meant for another patient. At 9:00 PM he is shaky and diaphoretic but alert, with a fingerstick glucose of 48 mg/dL. After oral glucose and intravenous dextrose, his glucose is 110 mg/dL at 11:00 PM and his symptoms have resolved. Hourly glucose checks are continuing. At 11:00 PM the ordering physician realizes that she entered the insulin order on the wrong patient's chart. The patient is now stable, with no neurologic deficit.

Which of the following is the most appropriate next step by the physician?
Pick one option. Your answers stay on this device.

Common questions

Do you have to disclose a medical error that caused no harm?

Yes. The AMA defines an error as something that harms or could harm a patient, so harm is not required, and disclosure applies even when the new information will not change treatment.

Who should disclose a medical error to the patient?

The physician involved, and promptly. Waiting for the patient to ask, or handing the conversation to someone else, does not meet that duty.

What should be said when disclosing an error?

What happened, what harm it may cause, and what the patient needs to know for later decisions. Include an acknowledgement and an apology, and the steps to prevent a repeat.

Why report an error to the hospital system?

The purpose is to study root causes and prevent the next error, not to punish. Report through the confidential reporting channel, even when nobody was harmed.

What if a colleague made the error?

Encourage them to disclose it. A colleague who is impaired or incompetent should be reported.

Transcript

Read the full narration, by chapter646 words

0:00The hook: an error nobody noticed, do you tell her?

A patient is given an antibiotic she is allergic to. Nothing happens. No rash, no drop in blood pressure. Nobody noticed except you. Do you tell her? Today: choose the right response to a medical error, which means disclosure, apology, and a report to the system.

0:19What counts as an error: harm or potential harm

The AMA Code of Medical Ethics defines an error as an unintended act or omission, or a flawed system or plan, that harms or could harm a patient. So an error does not have to cause harm. It only has to be able to. Patients have a right to know about their care, including conditions that resulted from an error. And worry about liability must not change a physician's honesty.

0:46Duty 1: disclose, promptly, even when treatment will not change

Three duties follow. Tell the patient. Apologize. Report to the system. First, disclose. The physician involved tells the patient, and does it promptly. Say what happened, what harm it may cause, and what the patient needs to know to make later decisions. That applies even when the new information will not change the treatment.

1:10Duty 2: acknowledge the error and apologize

Second, acknowledge the error and express real concern. Patients want a plain statement that an error happened, an explanation, the steps to prevent a repeat, and an apology. Keep caring for the patient, including helping them move to another physician if trust is lost.

1:29Duty 3: report to the system, and a colleague's error

Third, the system. Report the error through the hospital's confidential reporting channel, even when nobody was harmed. The purpose is to study root causes and prevent the next error, not to punish. If the error was a colleague's, encourage them to disclose it. And report a colleague who is impaired or incompetent.

1:50Worked example: a missed antibiotic dose, discovered late

Now apply it. A patient's morning antibiotic order never reaches the pharmacy, so one dose is missed. A colleague notices the next day. The infection is already improving, and she has no new symptoms. Do you disclose? Yes. The omission is an error even though no harm followed, and learning of it late is no reason to stay silent. Same for the allergy case: you tell her. Sit down with the patient, explain what happened, apologize, describe the change that stops it recurring, and file the report.

2:27Your turn: practice question

Your turn. A 64-year-old man without diabetes is recovering from an elective knee replacement. At eight p m he receives an insulin dose that was meant for another patient. An hour later his glucose is 48 milligrams per deciliter, and he is shaky and sweating but alert. After oral glucose and intravenous dextrose, his glucose is 110 and his symptoms resolve. Hourly glucose checks continue. At 11 p m, the ordering physician realizes she entered the order on the wrong chart. Which of the following is the most appropriate next step by the physician? A, inform him only if he develops lasting neurologic symptoms. B, record the event in the chart and discuss it only if he asks. C, defer disclosure until the hospital's legal department completes its review. D, inform him of the error, apologize, and submit a safety event report. E, ask the nurse who gave the dose to inform him. Pause here and decide.

3:36The answer: wrong options first, then D

A is out: errors are disclosed whether or not harm lasts, and he has already had hypoglycemia. B is out: waiting to be asked is not disclosure, since the physician involved should raise it promptly. C is out: liability concerns must not delay or shape honesty. E is out: the physician who made the error should disclose it, not hand it to the nurse. So the answer is D. The physician tells him, apologizes, and reports the event so the system can be fixed.

4:10High-yield recap and next lesson

Three things to keep. One: an error is anything that harms or could harm, so disclose even when no harm followed. Two: the physician involved discloses promptly, apologizes, explains the prevention plan, and keeps caring for the patient. Three: report every error, so the cause is fixed. Next, interpreters and health literacy.

Sources

Numbers in the text, e.g. [1], point here
  1. American Medical Association. Code of Medical Ethics, Opinion 8.6 Promoting Patient Safety. code-medical-ethics.ama-assn.org/ethics-opinions/promoting-patient-safety
  2. American Medical Association. Code of Medical Ethics, Opinion 9.4.2 Reporting Incompetent or Unethical Behaviors by Colleagues. code-medical-ethics.ama-assn.org/ethics-opinions/reporting-incompetent-or-unethical-behaviors-colleagues
  3. Open disclosure of patient safety incidents: narrative review. Clinics 2025. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC11964557
  4. Written disclosure of adverse events in a US health system. J Patient Saf 2018. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC5965928
  5. Disclosure and apology after medical error: review. Transl Androl Urol 2017. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC5583051
  6. Communication and resolution programs: AHRQ-commissioned review. J Patient Saf Risk Manag 2026. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC13298868
  7. Just culture and open disclosure: narrative review. Cureus 2025. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC12529216

Guideline basis: the AMA Code of Medical Ethics, Opinion 8.6 (Promoting Patient Safety), read on 13 Nov 2026, with the peer-reviewed sources below. This is the exam-standard US professional-ethics answer; US state law on disclosure and apology varies and is not taught here. UK practice (GMC, statutory duty of candour) differs and is not covered.

The practice question is original and its patient is synthetic. Every fact is checked against the sources above in independent accuracy reviews. Always follow your local guidelines and your own laboratory’s ranges.

Image credits. Illustrations: Servier Medical Art (smart.servier.com), CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), adapted (cut out, recoloured, outlined): "Caucasian elderly woman" (the patient) and "Doctor" (the physician and the colleague). Icons: Health Icons (healthicons.org), CC0 1.0 (no credit required): pills, register book, warning triangle, approved documents, syringe, glucometer, intravenous drip; recoloured and resized. The medication slip, definition, error lanes, three-duty banner, speech bubbles, report form and confidential box, fishbone, drug chart, question card, pocket card and all handwriting are drawn in code (original). No AI-generated teaching images.

Corrections. None so far. Spotted an error? Email info@medservatory.com with the lesson code MS-CK-ETH-005.

For exam study only, not medical advice. Read the medical disclaimer.

  1. EP 01Informed consent and decision-making capacity: the four abilities5:15
  2. EP 02Confidentiality exceptions: when you may or must disclose5:03
  3. EP 03Minors and consent: when a child can decide and when parents cannot4:50
  4. EP 04Advance directives and surrogate decision-makers: who decides?4:57
  5. EP 05Disclosing medical errors: disclose, apologize, report4:39
  6. EP 06Medical interpreter and teach-back: language and health literacy5:04